Home › Personal Insurance › Umbrella Insurance
A second layer of liability that starts paying when your auto or home policy hits its ceiling, for a few hundred dollars a year.
The layer above everything else
A personal umbrella adds $1 million or more of liability coverage above the limits on your auto and home policies, and pays legal defence costs along the way. For households across Delaware County with a house, cars, and savings to protect, it is the cheapest serious coverage we sell.
Liability is the open-ended risk in personal insurance. A kitchen fire has a worst case, roughly the value of the house. An at-fault crash with two injured people does not, and a verdict can reach your savings, your equity, and your future wages once the auto policy’s limit is spent.
The umbrella exists for exactly that gap. It sits quietly above everything, costs less than most people’s streaming subscriptions, and matters on precisely the worst day of your financial life.
The attachment point
An umbrella attaches where the underlying policy is exhausted. If your auto policy carries $250,000 per person in bodily injury liability and a claim settles at $600,000, the auto policy pays its $250,000 and the umbrella pays the remaining $350,000, plus the defence bills.
Run the arithmetic without the umbrella and the picture is uglier: the $350,000 balance belongs to you personally. Courts can reach non-exempt assets and future income to collect it. Owning a home makes you a more attractive defendant, not a better protected one.
The same layer stacks over a home policy’s liability, over rental properties when endorsed correctly, and over boats and motorcycles when the underlying policies qualify. One umbrella, several doors it can respond through.
Timing is the last piece worth naming. Nobody buys an umbrella the week they need it, because by then the incident has already happened. The households that carry one bought it on an ordinary Tuesday, precisely because the premium was small and the downside was not.
Cost
Published figures for a $1 million personal umbrella mostly land between roughly $300 and $600 a year. Households with teen drivers, rental properties, pools, or several vehicles price higher, because the umbrella sits above every one of those exposures at once.
Named sources, with their assumptions: Progressive puts the average at $383 a year for a household with one home, two cars, and two drivers. Mercury quotes a typical band of $300 to $600 a year based on its own policyholders. Coverage Cat reports $450 to $975 a year depending on state and household risk profile. Each additional million typically costs less than the first.
Cost sources: Progressive, Mercury Insurance, Coverage Cat. Retrieved August 2026. Your own premium depends on the household the umbrella sits above.
The qualifying hurdle
Carriers only sell umbrellas above policies that already carry substantial limits. Commonly quoted thresholds are auto liability around $250,000 per person and $500,000 per accident, and $300,000 of personal liability on the home policy, though each carrier sets its own.
This is the hidden cost of an umbrella: a household running state-minimum auto limits usually has to raise them before the umbrella can attach. That step is worth taking on its own merits, and once it is done, the umbrella above it is inexpensive for what it adds. We price the whole stack together so there are no surprises between layers, and no gap an adjuster can point at later.
Typical underlying thresholds as reported by Coverage Cat, retrieved August 2026. Carrier requirements vary.
Read this part
An umbrella is liability coverage, full stop. It extends your policies upward; it does not widen them sideways.
Why independent
Umbrella pricing looks simple until you notice it depends on everything underneath it. The carrier that wins your auto and home business is not automatically the one with the best umbrella terms above them, and some insurers quietly require the whole stack to move in-house before they will write the top layer.
Because we place auto insurance in Drexel Hill, PA and homeowners insurance in Drexel Hill, PA across five carriers, we can price the umbrella as part of the whole arrangement rather than as an afterthought. Landlords get the same treatment above landlord insurance in Delaware County, where the umbrella question is usually most urgent. The result is a stack with no seams, from the first dollar to the last million.
Questions
Tell us what sits underneath. We will quote the umbrella and any underlying changes together, with no obligation.
Get a QuoteCall (610) 259-6700